Partner content: This content was created by a business partner of Dow Jones, independent of the MarketWatch newsroom. Links in this article may result in us earning a commission. Learn More

The Best Pet Insurance Companies in Oklahoma (2024)

Did You Know?

5,534 pet owners requested and received a free no-obligation quote from one of the above companies in the last 30 days.


What’s the Best Pet Insurance in Oklahoma?

We conducted extensive research on pet insurance providers in Oklahoma and chose Lemonade as our top pick.

Here is our ranking of the best pet insurance providers in Oklahoma:

  • Lemonade: Cheapest plans for dogs 
  • Spot: Most customizable coverage
  • Embrace: Our pick for savings
  • Fetch: Our pick for comprehensive coverage
  • Healthy Paws: Most affordable unlimited coverage
  • Figo: Most flexible reimbursement rates
  • Trupanion: Our pick for unlimited lifetime payouts

Why Trust Us?

Here’s a breakdown of how we reviewed and rated the best pet insurance companies
35
Companies Reviewed Our team reviewed over 35 pet insurance companies, collecting and comparing data on monthly premiums, customizable coverage selections and more.
1000
Quotes Collected We’ve collected more than 1,000 sample quotes from pet insurance companies for a variety of age ranges, species and breeds to give readers an accurate view of pricing and how competitors stack up in terms of rates. We update our pages regularly to reflect accurate cost information.
42
Rating Factors Our comprehensive rating system scores providers based on 42 data points in eight key rating factors: monthly pricing, plan options, covered treatments, coverage customizations, customer care, industry reputation, age limits and waiting periods.
5
Veterinary Professionals We’ve consulted several veterinary professionals to confirm the accuracy of our pet care information and pricing.

The Best Pet Insurance Companies in Oklahoma Reviewed

Lemonade

Cheapest plans for dogs
4.8
Our Rating
Annual Limits $5k-$100k Deductibles $100-$500 Reimbursement Rates 70%-90%
MONTHLY COST $11-$20

Pros & Cons

Pros Offers transparency surrounding its fee structure, donations and profit scheme Cheapest plan for dogs in Oklahoma, based on our review Has the most add-ons of all plans we reviewed, meaning customers pay only for what they need Cons AI-based customer service can result in difficulty reaching human representatives compared to other Oklahoma providers May deny senior pets during enrollment

Why Lemonade Is No. 1 in Oklahoma

Lemonade earned 4.8 out of 5 stars based on our methodology and is our pick for the cheapest plans for dogs in Oklahoma. Lemonade plans provide basic accident and illness coverage, including diagnostic tests, medications and surgeries for a low price. It also offers customers a range of add-ons to extend coverage and customize monthly premiums. Lemonade uses artificial intelligence (AI) to speed up claims processing and reimbursements.

However, because Lemonade relies heavily on AI, some customers may find reaching a live person for assistance more difficult than with other providers. Like other insurers on our list, Lemonade does not cover pre-existing conditions or issues that occur during a waiting period.

Useful Coverage and Cost Information

According to our sample quotes, the average cost of a Lemonade plan in Oklahoma is $15 per month. To determine costs, we collected quotes from 11 popular providers in the state for four sample pets, including a 5-year-old medium, mixed-breed dog, a 2-year-old golden retriever, a 5-year-old mixed-breed cat and a 2-year-old Siamese cat.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dogs $20
Cats $11

When we compared annual premium costs to estimated annual pet ownership expenses in the state, including vet visits, emergencies, vaccines and medications, we determined policyholders could save $623 per year on pet health expenses with Lemonade.

Lemonade offers a basic plan and allows pet owners to pick and choose additional coverages for a customized policy. Available add-ons and associated average costs include:

  • Exam fees: $4 per month for dogs and $2 for cats
  • Dental illness: $12 per month for dogs and not available for cats
  • Behavioral conditions: $3–$4 per month
  • Physical therapy: $1–$2 per month
  • End-of-life remembrance: $2–$4 per month
  • Wellness: $15–$22 per month for dogs and $9–$15 for cats

Read our Lemonade Pet Insurance Review to learn more.

Spot Pet Insurance

Most Customizable Coverage
4.5
Our Rating
Annual Limits $2.5k-Unlimited Deductibles $100-$1k Reimbursement Rates 70%-90%
MONTHLY COST $9-$29

Pros & Cons

Pros Cheapest plan for cats and second-cheapest plans for dogs in Oklahoma, based on our review Offers several customization and plan options Offers good value for the money with all-inclusive plans Cons Does not offer a website chat feature Has a 14-day waiting period for accidents, compared to some other providers with two-day delays

Why Spot Is a Good Option

Spot earned 4.5 out of 5 stars as our pick for the most customizable coverage. While Lemonade uses add-ons to provide plan customizations, Spot offers inclusive plans with broad coverage and a range of deductibles, reimbursement rates and annual limit choices. Spot’s plans include some of the add-ons Lemonade offers as standard coverage, such as exam fees and dental illness. However, customers can customize certain aspects of their coverage to adjust monthly premiums.

Pricing and Coverage by Plan

According to our sample quotes, the average cost of a Spot plan in Oklahoma is $15 per month. After comparing annual premium costs to estimated annual pet ownership expenses, including veterinary visits, emergencies, vaccines and medications, we found policyholders could save $624 per year.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dogs $21
Cats $9

Spot also offers an accident-only plan, which costs $11 per month for dogs and $7 for cats. For wellness coverage, the Gold preventive care plan costs $10 per month and the Platinum plan costs $25.

Read our Spot Pet Insurance Review to learn more.

Embrace

Our Pick for Savings
4.7
Our Rating
Annual Limits $5k-$30k Deductibles $200-$1k Reimbursement Rates 70%-90%
MONTHLY COST $49-$96

Pros & Cons

Pros Offers multiple discount options for Oklahoma pet owners Has a unique and flexible wellness program Accident and illness plan offers the second-most customization options in Oklahoma, based on our review Cons Second-most expensive plans in Oklahoma of the companies on our list Limits coverage for new senior pet enrollments

Why Embrace Is a Good Option

Embrace earned 4.7 out of 5 stars and is our pick for savings in Oklahoma. Embrace offers discounts for multiple-pet homes, active and veteran military members, and customers in employee benefit programs. Embrace also values preventive care by providing a flexible wellness rewards program that differs from others on the market, allowing pet owners to spend wellness dollars as needed for vaccines, spay or neuter surgery, dental cleanings, grooming, or flea and tick medications. Embrace also rewards pet owners with a pet credit each year they go without filing a claim.

Pricing and Coverage by Plan

According to our sample quotes, the average cost of an Embrace plan in Oklahoma is $72 per month.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dogs $96
Cats $49

When we calculated annual premium costs compared to estimated annual pet ownership expenses, including vet visits, emergencies, medications and vaccines, we found that policyholders could lose $60 per year. However, this calculation represents an average and each pet owner’s experience will vary.

While Embrace offers optional exam fees and prescription drug coverage in some states, the company automatically includes these protections in Oklahoma policies. Pets enrolling after 15 years old must enroll in an accident-only plan, which is also available to younger pets when customers call to speak with an agent. The company also offers wellness rewards in addition to standard coverage with $250, $450 or $650 in annual benefits, costing an extra $18 to $52 per month.

Read our Embrace Pet Insurance Review to learn more.

Fetch Pet Insurance

Our Pick for Comprehensive Coverage
4.3
Our Rating
Annual Limits $5k-$15k Deductibles $250-$500 Reimbursement Rates 70%-90%
MONTHLY COST $45-$77

Pros & Cons

Pros Most comprehensive base plan available to Oklahoma pet owners in our review Offers a good value for pet owners who prefer holistic and natural veterinary care Partners with animal welfare groups to offer discounts for rescued pets Cons Fourth most expensive premiums of Oklahoma providers on our list Requires pet owners to upload their pet’s medical history with each claim, rather than reaching out to veterinarians directly

Why Fetch Is a Good Option

Fetch earned 4.3 out of 5 stars as our pick for the most comprehensive coverage in Oklahoma. All Fetch policies cover diagnostics and treatments related to pet accidents and illnesses, including exam fees, advanced dental care, and a full suite of holistic and alternative care options. Fetch also includes many emergency and non-veterinary benefits without charging extra, including lost pet advertising, virtual vet visits and emergency boarding fees if a pet’s caretaker becomes hospitalized.

Pricing and Coverage by Plan

According to our sample quotes, the average cost of a Fetch plan in Oklahoma is $61 per month.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dogs $77
Cats $45

When we compared annual premium costs to estimated annual pet ownership expenses, including vet visits, emergencies, vaccines and medications, we found policyholders could save $82 per year.

Fetch offers optional wellness benefits for an additional $11 to $32 per month.

Read our Fetch Pet Insurance Review to learn more.

Healthy Paws

Most Affordable Unlimited Coverage
4
Our Rating
Annual Limits Unlimited Deductibles $250-$1k Reimbursement Rates 50%-80%
MONTHLY COST $16-$39

Pros & Cons

Pros Most affordable unlimited plan available to Oklahoma pet owners, based on our review Offers fast claims reimbursements Plans offer deductibles as low as $100 Cons Only covers hip dysplasia in dogs 6 years or younger Reimbursement rate drops to 50% for senior pets, the lowest of the insurers on our list

Why Healthy Paws Is a Good Option

Healthy Paws earned 4 out of 5 stars as our pick for the most affordable unlimited coverage in Oklahoma. Although several other providers on our list offer unlimited annual coverage as an option, pet owners may see significant premium increases when they choose this feature. Healthy Paws plans never limit payouts and keep monthly costs down by cutting reimbursement rates when pets get older. However, Healthy Paws also has the most restrictive limitations regarding hip dysplasia coverage of the providers we reviewed.

Pricing and Coverage by Plan

According to our sample quotes, the average cost of a Healthy Paws plan in Oklahoma is $27 per month.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dogs $39
Cats $16

After calculating annual premiums and comparing estimated annual pet ownership expenses, including veterinary visits, emergencies, vaccines and medications, we determined Healthy Paws policyholders could save $481 per year.

Read our Healthy Paws Pet Insurance Review to learn more.

Figo

Most Flexible Reimbursement Rates
4.7
Our Rating
Annual Limits $5k-Unlimited Deductibles $100-$1.5k Reimbursement Rates 70%-100%
MONTHLY COST $22-$49

Pros & Cons

Pros Closes most claims in three days or less, which is the fastest of providers on our list operating on a reimbursement model Features average pricing in Oklahoma with a good balance of coverage and cost One of few Oklahoma providers offering a 100% reimbursement rate Cons Does not include exam fees in the base plan, unlike other top Oklahoma providers Has a separate orthopedic waiting period that requires additional steps at sign-up to ensure coverage

Why Figo Is a Good Option

Figo received 4.7 out of 5 stars in our review and is our pick for the most flexible reimbursement rates in Oklahoma. Figo has phased out many of its add-on coverages in favor of a more comprehensive plan. The company excludes exam fees and wellness services from its base plan to help keep premiums low, but pet owners can add coverage for an additional fee. Figo’s is also known for having fast reimbursement times, which it accomplishes through an AI-assisted mobile app.

Pricing and Coverage by Plan

According to our sample quotes, the average cost of a Figo plan in Oklahoma is $36 per month.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dogs $49
Cats $22

After calculating annual premium costs and estimated annual pet ownership expenses, including veterinary visits, emergencies, medications and vaccines, we found Figo policyholders could save $381 per year.

Figo’s base plan does not include exam fees, but you can add coverage for an average of $5 to $10 per month. The company also offers optional wellness benefits for an extra $10 or $17 each month.

Read our Figo Pet Insurance Review to learn more.

Trupanion

Our Pick for Unlimited Lifetime Payouts
4.2
Our Rating
Annual Limits Unlimited Deductibles $0-$1k Reimbursement Rates 90%
MONTHLY COST $34-$77

Pros & Cons

Pros Provides high reimbursement rates for the lifetime of Oklahoma pets Only provider on our list that prioritizes vet-direct payment as the primary reimbursement model Covers costs related to breeding and pregnancy, a service excluded by other insurers we reviewed Cons Requires Oklahoma pet owners to pay a one-time administrative fee at sign-up Add-on for physical and alternative therapy coverage is pricier than some competitors

Why Trupanion Is a Good Option

Trupanion earned 4.2 out of 5 stars and is our pick for unlimited lifetime payouts in Oklahoma. Trupanion is one of the original U.S. pet insurance providers and the first to base a business model on vet-direct payments. The company can pay partnering veterinarians directly at check-out or take the traditional approach in which pet owners file a claim for reimbursement after receiving services. Trupanion plans are some of the priciest on the market because the company offers unlimited lifetime payouts and 90% reimbursement on all policies.

Pricing and Coverage by Plan

According to our sample quotes, the average cost of a Trupanion plan is $56 per month in Oklahoma.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dogs $77
Cats $34

After comparing annual premium costs to estimated annual pet ownership expenses, including vet visits, emergencies, vaccines and medications, we found Trupanion policyholders could save $142 per year.

Trupanion does not offer wellness benefits but has two add-on coverages not included in its base plan, including:

  • Recovery and complementary care: This option includes chiropractic care, acupuncture, physical therapy and other alternative treatments for $5 to $15 per month.
  • Pet owner assistance: This option includes lost pet advertising, cremation and burial, property damage liability, emergency vacation cancellation and emergency boarding fees for $5 per month.

Read our Trupanion Pet Insurance Review to learn more.


Compare Oklahoma Pet Insurance Providers

The budgetary needs of pet owners vary, and no one plan fits every pet. Use the table below to compare providers side-by-side and based on the plan features most important to you.

Company Monthly Cost Star Rating Accident Waiting Period BBB Rating Visit Site
$15-$30
4.8
2 days B- EXPLORE PLANS
$34-$75
4.5
14 days A- EXPLORE PLANS
$39-$73
4.7
48 hours A+ EXPLORE PLANS
$45-$90
4.3
up to 15 days A+ EXPLORE PLANS
$24-$54
4.0
15 days A+ EXPLORE PLANS
$25-$54
4.7
1 days B EXPLORE PLANS
$53-$123
4.2
48 hours A+ EXPLORE PLANS
Company BBB Rating Monthly Cost Star Rating Accident Waiting Period Visit Site
B- $15-$30
4.8
2 days EXPLORE PLANS
A- $34-$75
4.5
14 days EXPLORE PLANS
A+ $39-$73
4.7
48 hours EXPLORE PLANS
A+ $45-$90
4.3
up to 15 days EXPLORE PLANS
A+ $24-$54
4.0
15 days EXPLORE PLANS
B $25-$54
4.7
1 days EXPLORE PLANS
A+ $53-$123
4.2
48 hours EXPLORE PLANS
No results were found.

How Much Does Pet Insurance Cost in Oklahoma?

We determined the average cost of a pet insurance plan in Oklahoma is $57 per month for dogs and $27 for cats by obtaining quotes from 11 popular providers in the state for four sample pets, including: 

  • a 5-year-old medium, mixed-breed male dog
  • A 2-year-old female golden retriever
  • A 5-year-old mixed-breed male cat
  • A 2-year-old female Siamese cat 

Pet insurance pricing varies depending on where you live and your pet’s breed and age. Plans can increase in cost as pets grow older because health issues may become more likely with age. If you own a purebred pet, you can also expect to pay more than with mixed breeds.

The table below shows the average costs of pet insurance plans in Oklahoma by provider and species.

ProviderDog InsuranceCat Insurance
Lemonade$20$11
Spot$21$9
Embrace$96$49
Healthy Paws$39$16
Fetch$77$45
Figo$49$22
Pets Best$34$15
Paw Protect$97$50
ASPCA Pet Health Insurance$39$16
ManyPets$25$13
Trupanion$77$34

What’s the Cheapest Pet Insurance in Oklahoma?

Our quote collection process revealed Lemonade and Spot as the cheapest pet insurance providers in Oklahoma. Each of these plans provides coverage in different ways. Lemonade focuses on technology and efficiency, while Spot provides comprehensive base coverage and traditional claims processing. We recommend pet owners consider multiple options at a variety of price points to determine which features they like best.


How To Choose the Best Pet Insurance in Oklahoma

We suggest Oklahoma pet owners consider all aspects of a plan and provider before choosing one that fits their needs. Some factors to keep in mind as you shop for pet insurance include the following:

  • Coverage and plan types: Accident-only plans provide coverage for accidental injuries, while accident and illness plans provide care for certain conditions at a higher monthly cost. Wellness coverage is not included in most plans, but you can buy it for an added monthly fee from many providers.
  • Fine print: Policy details vary considerably from plan to plan. Ensure you read a sample policy to understand limitations, exclusions and the claims process before you sign up.
  • Customization: Policy customizations allow you to customize your coverage and pricing to fit your budget. Look for plans with several deductibles, annual limits and reimbursement rates for maximum flexibility.
  • Customer satisfaction: Reading customer reviews on sites such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB), Trustpilot or Reddit can help you understand the strengths and weaknesses of each provider.

Pet insurance availability varies from state to state, depending on local insurance laws. Always obtain quotes from your top contenders to ensure a company operates in your area before investing your time and energy in extensive research.


What Are the Pet Laws in Oklahoma?

Oklahoma state pet laws regulate vaccination, sterilization, dangerous dogs, responsible pet ownership and animal cruelty. Additionally, pet owners must follow laws set forth by their cities, towns or counties. We included a few examples in Oklahoma below for reference. 

Oklahoma City Pet Laws

  • Owners cannot leave dogs outdoors for more than 30 minutes when the temperature is below 32 F.
  • After emergencies or disasters, officials cannot remove lost animals from the city for at least 30 days, giving owners a chance to reclaim their pets.
  • Residents may keep a maximum of four dogs and four cats.

Tulsa Pet Laws

  • Pet training is not allowed on public highways, streets or alleys.
  • License fees for dogs and cats may change as recommended by the Animal Welfare Commission and approved by the city council.
  • Residents are limited to owning a combination of five dogs and cats.

Norman Pet Laws

  • Impounded pets are subject to a three-day stray hold, but this increases to five days when pets are microchipped or wear a valid rabies tag.
  • Owners must have a license for all pets in the city, but the city waives fees for animals adopted from the city shelter. The city also discounts fees for senior citizens and current or veteran military.
  • Owners must continuously supervise tethered pets to ensure their safety.

Understanding Pet Insurance Terminology 

Learning pet insurance terms can help pet owners understand how pet insurance works. Here are a few important definitions:

  • A waiting period is the time between when you purchase your policy and when coverage begins. Waiting periods range from one day for accidents up to a year for orthopedic conditions.
  • A deductible is the amount you pay toward covered services before the plan will contribute. Deductibles typically apply annually, but some plans may also have per-incident deductibles.
  • Premiums are the monthly payments you make to purchase an insurance policy. You can generally expect premiums to increase as your pet gets older or, in some cases, in response to certain claims.
  • A reimbursement rate is how much of each bill you can expect your plan to reimburse after you meet your deductible. Common reimbursement rates include 70%, 80% or 90%. 
  • A coverage limit determines the maximum reimbursement you can receive in a given policy term, per incident or throughout your pet’s lifetime.

Is Pet Insurance Worth It in Oklahoma?

Pet insurance can offer Oklahoma pet owners a way to prepare for large or ongoing veterinary bills. Serious medical issues can happen when you least expect it, and pet insurance can offer peace of mind in the event of a pet emergency. Although you may go several years without filing claims, reimbursements for a single major incident often exceed the lifetime cost of pet insurance premiums. 

According to our research, the best plans for Oklahoma pet owners are Lemonade, Spot and Embrace. We encourage pet parents to research their options, use our comparison tools, and obtain quotes to determine which provider best fits their pet’s needs and budget.


Frequently Asked Questions About Pet Insurance in Oklahoma

According to Healthy Paws pet insurance data, the most common health issues submitted as claims in Oklahoma include skin problems, ear infections, stomach issues, pain and diabetes. As long as your pet does not already have these conditions when you purchase a policy, pet insurance can cover initial and ongoing costs relating to these common pet health problems.

 

Many pet insurance companies exclude coverage for pet health problems caused by war or nuclear radiation, but most do not limit coverage based on weather conditions or natural disasters. If your pet gets injured in a tornado or suffers heat stroke during a heat wave, insurance should cover their injuries. However, insurance will not cover issues caused by an owner’s neglectful actions, such as leaving a pet in a hot car. Also, you typically must file claims within a specified time frame to receive reimbursement, even if a disaster displaced you.

 

Standard accident and illness pet insurance typically excludes coverage for preventive care, such as flea and tick preventives. However, many providers allow you to purchase add-on wellness coverage that may include reimbursement for flea and tick medications. If your pet gets sick with a tick- or flea-borne disease, your insurer may require you to show proof of administering preventive medications to obtain coverage for the disease.

 


How We Ranked the Best Pet Insurance Providers in Oklahoma

We ranked Oklahoma pet insurance providers by assigning each insurer a star rating based on an objective scale, incorporating scores for pricing, customer service, plan types, customization options, industry reputation and customer reviews. We then ranked providers according to availability and if coverage options meet the needs of Oklahoma pets based on survey results and data on common pet health conditions in the region.

We obtained cost data using a sample quote collection process. Sample pets included a 5-year-old medium, mixed-breed dog, a 2-year-old golden retriever, a 5-year-old mixed-breed cat and a 2-year-old Siamese cat. For more information on our quote collection process, star ratings and provider rankings, please visit our full pet insurance methodology and editorial guidelines pages.


Additional Pet Insurance Resources

Elizabeth Kowalski, CVT Certified Veterinary Technician

Elizabeth Kowalski holds a bachelor’s degree in biology from the University of Illinois and an associate’s degree in veterinary technology from Purdue University. After more than 10 years working as a certified veterinary technician, she chose to pursue veterinary writing, combining years of practical knowledge with a talent and passion for the written word. She has been featured in industry publications such as Today’s Veterinary Business. Elizabeth enjoys creating content for pet owners and veterinary professionals alike, and spends her free time playing sand volleyball and lounging at home with her pitbull, Piglet, and husband, Brenton.

Tori Addison Editor

Tori Addison is an editor who has worked in the digital marketing industry for over five years. Her experience includes communications and marketing work in the nonprofit, governmental and academic sectors. A journalist by trade, she started her career covering politics and news in New York’s Hudson Valley. Her work included coverage of local and state budgets, federal financial regulations and health care legislation.

Angela Beal, DVM Doctor of Veterinary Medicine

Angela Beal, DVM, loves using her writing to help pet owners provide the best possible care for their furry companions. Angela has worked in private practice and taught veterinary technicians for 15 years. Since 2020, she has worked full-time with Rumpus Writing and Editing, a veterinary-specific writing and editing company. Angela lives in Columbus, Ohio with her husband, two sons, and their spoiled Chihuahua mix, Yogi.

Array
(
    [display] => Array
        (
        )

    [icon] => 
    [text] => 
    [cta] => Array
        (
            [title] => 
            [url] => 
            [target] => _blank
        )

    [toggle] => closeable
)