Best Pet Insurance In New York (2022 Review)

by | 11/01/2022

Jump To: Best Pet Insurance Companies In New York | How Pet Insurance Works in New York | Choosing the Best Pet Insurance in New York | Cost of Pet Insurance in New York | Final Thoughts | Information for Pet Owners | FAQs | Methodology

 The pet insurance industry is a multi-billion dollar market that has seen an increase in recent years. As the number of pets increases, so does the need for pet insurance in New York. Pet owners are beginning to realize what it would be like without their furry best friend around and want to make sure they can take care of them if something were to happen. 

You can find many different types of policies that fit your needs and budget, but here are some things you should consider before you buy one:

  • Does it cover significant illnesses?
  • Does it cover accidents?
  • What about pre-existing conditions?
  • Do I have enough coverage?
  • Are there any age restrictions on my pet?
  • What is the annual limit for coverage?
  • Is there a deductible on my plan?

We’ll review the following providers to help you find the best pet insurance in New York:

 

Top 6 Best Pet Insurance Companies In New York

Everyone loves their pets, so it is vital to get the best insurance you can afford. Many pet insurance companies offer policies to those living in New York. Furthermore, a lot offer low monthly payments and have excellent customer service reviews. 

Here is our list of the best pet insurance companies for those who live in the great state of New York:

Provider Free Quote Waiting Period Money-back Guarantee Maximum Enroll Age BBB Rating
Spot Visit Site 14 days* Yes No age limit A
Lemonade Visit Site 14 days for illnesses*, 48 hours for accidents  No 14 years old F
Embrace Visit Site 14 days for illnesses*, 48 hours for accidents Yes 14 years old A+
Healthy Paws Visit Site 15 days* Yes 14 years old A-
ASPCA Visit Site 15 days*  Yes No age limit N/A
Prudent Pet Visit Site 5 days for accidents, 14 days for illnesses*  Yes No age limit A+
*Certain conditions, such as cruciate ligaments or orthopedic conditions, may have longer waiting period times, usually six months to a year. This is common among many pet insurance providers, but most illnesses will be covered after the waiting period listed above. 

Spot Pet Insurance

Spot Pet Insurance is a straightforward way to ensure that your pet receives the medical care it requires when it is most needed. Spot is neither challenging to use nor complicated — you simply visit your veterinarian, file a claim after treatment, and wait for payment. In addition, you may choose the amount of coverage you want and customize the policy to fit your pet’s needs and financial restrictions.

How Much Does Spot Pet Insurance Cost In New York?

The average cost for dogs is around $30 a month and around $25 a month for cats. Spot is underwritten by Crum & Forster Pet Insurance. Spot is customizable with an annual maximum of $2,500. It also provides a variety of preventative health packages for an extra fee and a 10% multi-pet discount on pets added to the policy. Spot likewise has plans that don’t have an annual limit. 

What Is Covered?

  • Prescription medication
  • End of life expenses
  • X-rays
  • Tooth extractions
  • Stem cell therapy
  • Poison control
  • IV fluids 
  • Cancer treatment
  • Blood tests
  • Accidents
  • Emergency care
  • Surgery
  • Hospitalization

What Is NOT Covered?

There are, of course, disadvantages. Spot’s coverage doesn’t include dental treatment, gland expression, preventive care, vitamins, experimental treatments, cosmetic procedures, or home visits.

Pros:

  • No age limit
  • Multi-pet discount
  • 30-day money back

Cons:

  • No preventive care
  • 14-day waiting period

Learn More: Spot Pet Insurance Review

ASPCA Pet Insurance

The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals® (ASPCA®) is one of the world’s largest humane societies founded first in North America. Hartville Pet Insurance Group, which began operations in 2006 and is one of the most established and renowned pet insurance providers in the United States, provides pet insurance for the ASPCA.

ASPCA has three plan levels: accident only, injuries and illnesses, and injuries, illnesses, and advanced care. All plans include a 14-day waiting period.

How Much Does ASPCA Pet Insurance Cost In New York?

Add-on preventative care plans can help you stay on top of your pet’s health. The typical dog coverage cost is $48.78, while the average cat coverage cost is $29.16.

What Is Covered?

  • Cancer treatments
  • Microchipping
  • End of life expenses
  • IV fluids and medications
  • Stem cell therapy
  • Prescription foods
  • Supplements for specific conditions
  • Tooth extractions
  • Exams
  • Medical supplies

What Is NOT Covered?

The issues and procedures ASPCA insurance doesn’t cover are pretty standard. Its policy will not include dental aesthetics and cleanings, boarding, pre-existing conditions, and conditions prone to specific breeds.

Pros: 

  • Range of deductibles
  • Various coverage options

Cons:

  • No pre-existing conditions
  • No Treatment for breed-specific conditions

Learn More: ASPCA Pet Insurance Review

Lemonade Pet Insurance

Lemonade offers a wide range of insurance options. Lemonade also sells home, renters’, and auto insurance in addition to pet insurance. Lemonade Pet Insurance is now available in 35 states, with more to come.

Lemonade is unlike other insurance companies in that it is not exclusively concerned with profit. Instead, premiums are used to cover claims. At the end of the year, any unspent money is returned to its clients’ preferred causes. It also provides multi-pet discounts and a 10% discount if you have your home insured with the company. Currently, it only offers coverage for cats and dogs.

How Much Does Lemonade Pet Insurance Cost In New York?

Lemonade gives customers the option of paying monthly. The average cost of a cat is $15 per month, whereas the average cost for a dog is $37 per month. You may also choose to add a preventative package to your policy for an extra charge. For cats, it starts at $10 per month and rises to $15 per month if you select the highest level. 

Depending on the extent of coverage, Lemonade might provide up to $100,000 in coverage and annual deductibles ranging from $500 to $5,000. Remember that the cost will vary based on species, gender, and age.

What Is Covered?

  • Blood tests
  • MRIs
  • CT scans
  • X-rays
  • Urinalysis
  • Lab work
  • Ultrasounds
  • Outpatient procedures
  • Specialty care
  • Emergency care
  • Surgery
  • Hospitalization
  • Medications

What Is NOT Covered?

When considering Lemonade, what it doesn’t cover is one thing to keep in mind. Pre-existing ailments, preventable illnesses, problems that develop during the waiting period, and experimental therapies are all examples of things that aren’t covered.

Pros

  • Customization options
  • Multi-pet discount
  • Fast claim with mobile app

Cons:

  • Still new to the pet insurance market
  • No posted money-back guarantee

Learn More: Lemonade Pet Insurance Review

Embrace Pet Insurance

Embrace was formed in 2003 and has insured over 100,000 pets. It also gives $2 to a pet-related charity for every policy sold. Embrace has been working with American Modern Insurance Group since 2012 as the underwriter for its policies.

How Much Does Embrace Pet Insurance Cost In New York?

Plans average $30 to $40 per month for dogs and $15 to $20 per month for cats. Remember, rates will vary based on age, gender, and breed. 

There are several discounts available, depending on your location. For example, Embrace gives a 10% multi-pet discount, a 5% military discount, ACH savings, spay/neuter savings, and a monthly payment difference if you pay yearly rather than every month.

Embrace also has some exciting ideas for the future. Its Embrace Wellness Rewards is one such idea. Preventative care reimburses for regular veterinary training and grooming expenses. Embrace also provides a Healthy Pet Deductible, stated in its terms and conditions. If you don’t make a claim every year, your pet’s annual deductible goes down by $50 every year.

What Is Covered?

  • Exam & consultation fees
  • Diagnostic tests
  • Emergency 
  • Specialty care
  • Surgery 
  • Cancer treatments
  • Hospitalization
  • Behavioral therapy
  • Follow-up care
  • Rehabilitation
  • Prosthetic limbs
  • Prescription medications 
  • Breed-specific issues
  • Congenital illness
  • Chronic conditions

What Is NOT Covered?

Embrace’s list of what isn’t covered is better than some other insurers’ plans, in our opinion. However, pregnancy, pre-existing conditions, deliberate injury, cosmetic treatments, DNA testing, and stem cell therapy are excluded from Embrace’s coverage. Remember that premiums will vary depending on your pet’s age, gender, and breed. Lastly, Embrace presently only covers cats and dogs.

Pros:

  • Money-back guarantee
  • Mobile app for immediate claim access
  • Wellness Rewards Program

Cons:

  • Long illness waiting period
  • Lower annual maximums compared to others

Learn More: Embrace Pet Insurance Review

Healthy Paws Pet Insurance

Healthy Paws was established in 2009 as a nonprofit to help pet owners with financial obligations for their animals while assisting animal rescue organizations with sick pets.

Healthy Paws has joined forces with the global insurance broker Aon Corporation, and Chubb Group backs its pet insurance plans. Healthy Paws insurance covers accidents, illnesses, cancer, emergency care, genetic conditions, dental care, and alternative therapies like acupuncture and chiropractic.

How Much Does Healthy Paws Pet Insurance Cost In New York?

The most notable features are a 30-day money-back guarantee, customizable coverage, and a one-time new customer fee of $25. In addition, the monthly cost for dogs is $39, while cats cost $12 each month on average.

What Is Covered?

  • Prescription medication
  • End of life expenses
  • X-rays
  • Tooth extractions
  • Stem cell therapy
  • Poison control
  • IV fluids 
  • Cancer treatment
  • Blood tests
  • Accidents
  • Emergency care
  • Surgery
  • Hospitalization

What Is NOT Covered?

Now the bad news, some of the services you’ll have to pay for out of pocket include pre-existing conditions, examination costs, preventative care, behavioral treatment, pet diets, and non-FDA treatment or supplements.

Pros:

  • Covers breed-specific conditions
  • No limits on coverage
  • Good BBB rating
  • Fast claim repayment

Cons:

  • New member fee
  • No preventive care benefits

Learn More: Healthy Paws Pet Insurance Review

Prudent Pet Insurance

Prudent Pet was founded in 2018, making it one of the newest pet insurers in the business. Despite this, plans are insured by far more well-known names in the insurance sector. Also, Markel underwrites all of its policies.

Transparent and easy-to-understand policies are among Prudent’s strengths. The company provides various coverage options for pet owners, including comprehensive and accident-only plans. Coverage limits start at $10,000 and can have no limit if you choose to go with the highest tier policy. 

How Much Does Prudent Pet Insurance Cost In New York?

The cost of monthly premiums varies greatly depending on your pet’s breed, age, and gender. Some plans start at $10 per month for dogs and cats, with the average being around $39 per month for dogs and $23 per month for cats. Prudent also offers add-on pet wellness plans starting at $7.95 per month for cats and $11.95 per month for dogs.

What Is Covered?

  • Cancer and treatments
  • Bite wounds
  • Broken bones
  • Emergency care
  • Hospitalization
  • Surgery
  • Congenital defects
  • Eye, ear, and skin conditions
  • Urinary infections
  • Hereditary conditions
  • Hip dysplasia

What Is NOT Covered?

Prudent does not cover prescription food, organ transplants, non-emergency dental work, intervertebral disc disease, and knee issues. Make sure you keep this in mind when considering it for a policy.

Pros: 

  • Customization options
  • Offers a multi-pet discount
  • No upper age limit

Cons:

  • Higher premiums than other companies
  • High amount of exclusions

Learn More: Prudent Pet Insurance Review

How Does Pet Insurance Work in New York?

Purchasing pet insurance in New York can be a great way to ensure your furry friend receives the best routine care possible, no matter what. Most pet insurance companies offer various coverage options and will reimburse you for a wide range of treatments and procedures your pet may need. However, reading the fine print before signing up is essential, as each company has different exclusions.

Generally, pet insurance works like any other insurance policy. You pay a monthly or annual premium, and if your pet needs treatment, you file a claim with the insurance company, which then reimburses you for a portion of the treatment cost. Keep in mind that there is a waiting period of 14 days from when you sign up for your policy to when you can file a claim. The amount of time and money reimbursed varies by plan, so it’s always best to read the fine print before signing up.

How to Choose the Best Pet Insurance in New York for You

Before deciding on a pet insurance policy, you’ll first need to consider your budget. Also, what kind of coverage are you looking for? To make sure everything is covered, it’s a good idea to have two different policies that together can cover any significant expense.

While the average cost of premiums will vary from company to company, certain factors can push costs up or down. For example, if you live in an area where pets frequently require treatment, such as New York City, it’s going to be more expensive than living in a small town with a low incidence of accidents and illness. Likewise, if you own a purebred dog (such as a poodle), your premiums will generally be higher than they would be for a mixed breed.

The next step is to read the fine print and understand what isn’t covered by each policy. Each company has different exclusions, so knowing what treatments and procedures your pet will be eligible for before signing up is essential.

Finally, don’t forget to ask around for recommendations. Friends, family, and your veterinarian are all excellent sources of information (along with 365 Pet Insurance) when it comes to finding the best pet insurance in New York for you and your furry friend.

How Much is Pet Insurance in New York?

Provider Sample Monthly Cost For Dogs Sample Monthly Cost For Cats Sample Monthly Wellness Cost
Spot Average $30-$50/month Average $18-$25/month Starting at $9.95
Lemonade Average $37/month  Average $15/month  Cats start at $10

Dogs start at $15

Embrace Average $30-$40/month Average $15-$20/month Start at $18.75/month
Healthy Paws Average $39/month Average $12/month N/A
ASPCA $48.78  $29.16 N/A
Prudent Pet Average $39/month Average $23/month Cats start at $7.95 and dogs at $11.95

We obtained a few test quotes with New York City as the destination to determine the costs in that city. For the cost, we used a 3-year-old mixed-breed dog weighing 21-70 pounds with a $14,000 annual benefit package and a $250 deductible. Of course, the price will vary depending on what you pick in the plan and where you live. Manhattan was found to be the most expensive, followed by Brooklyn, whereas the remainder of the state appeared to be more aligned with pet insurance rates throughout the country.

City or Borough Monthly Cost
Manhattan $65.79
Brooklyn $57.04
Albany $39.29
Buffalo $43.54
Syracuse $45.67

If you choose a cat, the pet insurance cost will be a lot less. For example, it’s about half as expensive to cover a cat in Manhattan, which costs around $38.

With the average cost of pet routine care rising, and better access to more expensive therapies, an emergency vet visit or accident can cost quite a bit. Here’s a look at some data from CBS News on pet care costs (as of 2016):

  • Joint injuries: $3,456
  • Cancer: $2,039
  • Swallowing foreign objects: $1,728
  • Lameness: $986
  • Intestinal problems: $857
  • Periodontal disease: $850
  • Allergies: $803

As most things do, the cost of veterinary care is expected to continue to rise, and numbers in NYC will climb even higher as rising rents, cost of equipment, salaries and more also rise in the largest city in our nation.

Final Thoughts

In the end, pet insurance is a smart choice for most owners. It’s beneficial for those with dogs — purebred or not — who like to go on long walks and hikes where they may find themselves in an accident. Of course, there’s no such thing as perfect coverage (there will always be exclusions), but you can’t put a price on peace of mind.

Now that you’ve finished our guide, you’re ready to take action and get yourself a new pet policy. Don’t forget that 365 Pet Insurance is here to help provide you with all the information you need! 

Information for Pet Owners in New York

Living in New York with a pet can be exciting. There’s never a dull moment, from the many dog parks to the abundance of outdoor activities. But along with the fun comes specific responsibilities, such as ensuring your pet is always safe and healthy. 

Here is some valuable information for pet owners in New York, including laws, things to do, and places you can turn to for help.

New York Pet Laws

Just like every other state, New York has a set of laws that you must follow if you want to have a pet. Here are a few worth noting:

  • New York State requires all dogs over four months of age to be licensed.
  • NYC requires that you fulfill additional criteria if you have a guard or service dog. These dogs must be registered, and any transfer of ownership must be reported to the city within five days. Furthermore, a guard dog’s dog license tag and its city-issued guardian dog tag must both be worn on its collar.
  • While there is no statewide leash law, each state area has its mandates. e.g., in NYC, dogs must be on a leash no longer than six feet. In addition, you can’t chain up a dog for more than three hours.

Fun Things to Do With Your Pet in NY

New York is a big state. From the bustling streets of Manhattan to the frigid winters in Buffalo, a lot is going on. This makes for a great place to have a pet. Here are just a few of the things you can do with your pet in New York:

  • Check out Central Park
  • Ride the Staten Island Ferry
  • Go Shopping
  • Grab a Bite to Eat 
  • Create a work of art with Puppy Picasso
  • Take a walk on Prospect Park Dog Beach

New York Pet Resources

Everyone needs help sometimes. Here are some resources to keep handy for when times are tough:

Frequently Asked Questions About Pet Insurance in New York

Does pet insurance only cover dogs and cats? 

Most pet insurance providers only cover dogs and cats. To date, the only pet insurance provider that covers birds and exotic pets in the United States is Nationwide Insurance. Nationwide can cover your pet pig, lizard, parrot, chinchilla, and other exotic animals. Exotic pets need excellent veterinary care just as much as dogs and cats, so consider looking into a pet insurance plan for them today if you have an exotic pet.

Is buying pet insurance worth it in New York? 

For most pet owners, pet insurance is absolutely worth it. We never know when our pet could have an unexpected accident or develop an illness, so having a backup plan in place to help pay for your pet’s vet bills is beneficial for most pet parents. Vet bills can quickly add up to hundreds, or even thousands of dollars, which many pet parents don’t have readily available. 

Having pet insurance protects you financially and gives you peace of mind that you won’t have to say no to recommended treatments to benefit your pet’s health and happiness.

What does Pet Insurance Typically Cover?

Depending on what type of plan you choose, your pet insurance plan will cover different things. Accident-only plans provide medical coverage for accidental injuries, such as broken bones, sprains, and prescription medications. Accident-and-illness plans try to extend that coverage to include cancer treatments, digestive illness, hip dysplasia, and similar issues.

Our Methodology

The 365 Pet Insurance research team looks at all pet insurance policies and comes up with our reviews based on coverage, plan options, cost, reputation, customer service, and species eligibility. We’ve also created a rating system to score pet insurance brands.

We’ve consulted with pet experts and dug into plans to develop what we think are the best overall plans, complete with ratings on coverage, how they handle claims, reimbursements, deductibles, limits, and more.

To make our list, pet insurance companies must have:

  • A variety of plan options
  • Affordable monthly rates

Our team revisits each company’s information at the end of every month to make updates and ensure the information is as accurate as possible.