Partner content: This content was created by a business partner of Dow Jones, independent of the MarketWatch newsroom. Links in this article may result in us earning a commission. Learn More

The Best Pet Insurance Companies in Missouri (2024)

Did You Know?

5,534 pet owners requested and received a free no-obligation quote from one of the above companies in the last 30 days.

Rankings of The Best Pet Insurance Providers in Missouri

The best pet insurance providers in Missouri based on our comprehensive rating system are:

Why Trust Us?

Here’s a breakdown of how we reviewed and rated the best pet insurance companies
35
Companies Reviewed Our team reviewed over 35 pet insurance companies, collecting and comparing data on monthly premiums, customizable coverage selections and more.
1000
Quotes Collected We’ve collected more than 1,000 sample quotes from pet insurance companies for a variety of age ranges, species and breeds to give readers an accurate view of pricing and how competitors stack up in terms of rates. We update our pages regularly to reflect accurate cost information.
42
Rating Factors Our comprehensive rating system scores providers based on 42 data points in eight key rating factors: monthly pricing, plan options, covered treatments, coverage customizations, customer care, industry reputation, age limits and waiting periods.
5
Veterinary Professionals We’ve consulted several veterinary professionals to confirm the accuracy of our pet care information and pricing.

What’s the Best Pet Insurance in Missouri?

We analyzed several pet insurance providers in Missouri and Spot came out on top for its customizable coverage and other standout features.

Spot Pet Insurance

Most Customizable Coverage
4.5
Our Rating
Annual Limits $2.5k-Unlimited Deductibles $100-$1k Reimbursement Rates 70%-90%
MONTHLY COST $29-$78

Pros and Cons

Pros No upper age limit when enrolling pets No payout limit per incident or maximum lifetime caps Includes veterinary exam fees for covered conditions Cons 14-day waiting period for accidents — longer than others on our list Considers a knee injury a bilateral condition if the pet had a knee injury that occurred before or during the waiting period, denying coverage No option to pay the veterinarian directly

Why Spot Pet Insurance Is #1 in Missouri

We rated Spot 4.5 out of 5 stars based on our provider review methodology. Spots’s hallmark feature is its customization — the company lets you choose from several deductibles, annual coverage limits and reimbursement rates. Spot also extends discounts to Missouri residents who own multiple pets, which is a perk for some.

The provider has a few downsides, though. Spot’s 14-day waiting period for accidents may be a potential drawback for Missouri pet parents. Some providers we reviewed delay accident coverage for only two days.

Spot Pricing and Coverage By Plan

After collecting sample quotes for representative pets, including a 5-year-old medium, mixed breed dog, a 2-year-old golden retriever, a 5-year-old mixed-breed cat and a 2-year old Siamese cat, we determined that the average cost for a Spot policy in Missouri is $53 per month.

We compared this data to the estimated healthcare costs of annual pet ownership in Missouri, which we calculated at around $831 for veterinary visits, emergencies, medications and vaccines, and found that Spot policyholders could save $195 per year.

Accident and Illness Coverage Average Monthly Cost
Dog Insurance $78
Cat Insurance $29

As a Spot policyholder, you can opt for a stripped-down accident-only plan or a more comprehensive accident and illness plan. In either case, you can get preventive care coverage with one of the following add-ons:

  • Gold plan: Additional $10 per month for dogs and cats
  • Platinum plan: Additional $25 per month for dogs and cats

Learn more about the company in our Spot Pet Insurance review.


What Other Pet Insurance Providers Operate in Missouri?

Healthy Paws

Most Affordable Unlimited Coverage
4.0
Our Rating
Annual Limits Unlimited Deductibles $250-$1k Reimbursement Rates 50%-80%
MONTHLY COST $20-$50

Pros and Cons

Pros Operates a foundation to help animal rescue organizations Unlimited coverage on all plans Processes most claims in two days, according to its website Cons Cons No add-on wellness coverage 12-month waiting period for hip dysplasia if your pet is less than six years old, and no coverage for the condition if it’s older Imposes a long 15-day waiting period for accidents, compared to other companies on our list

Why Healthy Paws Is a Good Option

Earning 4 out 5 stars, Healthy Paws deserves a spot on our list for covering genetic, hereditary and breed-related conditions —  an uncommon perk compared to some other insurance providers we reviewed. Missouri pet owners can also take advantage of Healthy Paws’ flexible premium and deductible options and its unlimited coverage on all plans.

While some Missouri pet owners may appreciate the simplicity of Healthy Paws’ single plan, those who want wellness coverage for their pet will be disappointed. The policy offers no preventive add-on options.

Healthy Paws Pricing and Coverage By Plan

Based on our research, Missouri pet parents can expect to pay an average of $35 per month for a Healthy Paws policy. We compared this average fee to the estimated annual pet ownership expenses such as veterinary visits, vaccinations, medications and emergencies. Taking everything into account, we then determined that Show-Me State pet owners could save $409 per year by investing in a Healthy Paws policy.

Accident and Illness Coverage Average Monthly Cost
Dog Insurance $50
Cat Insurance $20

Healthy Paws doesn’t offer an option to add on wellness coverage, but Missouri pet owners can customize their plans by adjusting their reimbursement rates and annual deductibles to arrive at a premium that fits their budgets.

To discover more about this provider, read our Healthy Paws Pet Insurance review.

Figo

Most Flexible Reimbursement Rates
4.7
Our Rating
Annual Limits $5k-Unlimited Deductibles $100-$1.5k Reimbursement Rates 70%-100%
MONTHLY COST $19-$41

Pros and Cons

Pros Can provide claims processing within a few business days, according to the company website Offers discounts for multiple pets and members of the military Short one-day waiting period for accidents Cons Uses your pet’s first veterinary exam after the policy begins to determine pre-existing conditions if your pet hasn’t had an exam within the last 12 months Requires at least a $500 deductible to access its 100% reimbursement option

Why Figo Is a Good Option

We award Figo 4.7 out of 5 stars. It offers flexible plans and covers curable pre-existing conditions when the pet shows no signs of the condition for 12 months after its last treatment. In addition, Figo offers a 24/7 helpline, giving Show-Me State pet owners the opportunity to seek advice from a licensed veterinary professional at any time.

Budget-conscious Missouri pet owners looking for accident-only coverage won’t find it at Figo, according to our research. However, its accident and illness plans cost less than the state average, based on the cost estimates of providers we reviewed.

Figo Pricing and Coverage By Plan

Based on our sample quotes process, the average price for a Figo policy in Missouri is $30 per month. We calculated the annual premium cost and compared this to the average pet owner expenses, including veterinary visits, vaccines, medications and emergencies, and found that a Show-Me State pet parent could save $470 per year by purchasing a Figo policy.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dog Insurance $41
Cat Insurance $19

After customizing your plan by choosing a reimbursement rate and deductible, you can opt to add on additional coverage, including:

  • Exam fees: Additional $8 per month for dogs and $3 per month for cats
  • Wellness plan basic: Additional $10 per month for dogs and cats
  • Wellness plan plus: Additional $17 per month for dogs and cats

Interested in learning more? Our Figo Pet Insurance review has you covered.

Embrace

Our Pick for Savings
4.7
Our Rating
Annual Limits $5k-$30k Deductibles $200-$1k Reimbursement Rates 70%-90%
MONTHLY COST $35-$68

Pros and Cons

Pros Offers a 5% monthly premium discount in the first year and a 10% premium discount in the second year for pet owners whose annual reimbursements are less than $300 Short two-day waiting period for accidents Covers exam fees, prescription medications, dental disease and specialist care Cons Limits pets 15 years and older to accident-only coverage Doesn’t cover prescription food unless you pay for an add-on

Why Embrace Is a Good Option

Earning 4.7 out of 5 stars, Embrace is our top pick for savings. Its plans cover emergency care, hospitalization, surgery, diagnostic testing, prescription drugs and specialist care, as well as some complementary treatments and rehabilitation. The company also offers Missouri pet parents the option to add on a wellness reward program for reimbursement for preventive care such as grooming, nail trims, spay or neuter surgery and dental cleanings.

Embrace may not be the best option for Missouri residents who have senior pets since dogs and cats 14 years and older are only eligible for an accident-only plan.

Embrace Pricing and Coverage By Plan

Based on our sample quotes, Show-Me State pet owners can expect to pay about $52 per month for an Embrace pet insurance policy. Comparing premium costs to expected pet health, we determined that Missouri pet parents could save $211 per year by investing in an Embrace policy.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dog Insurance $68
Cat Insurance $35

Embrace policyholders in Missouri can choose three different levels of wellness rewards coverage for an additional $19 per month for the base plan, $35 per month for the mid-range plan and $52 per month for the premium plan.

Read our Embrace Pet Insurance review for more information.

Wagmo

Most Wellness Plan Options
4.3
Our Rating
Annual Limits $10k-$100k Deductibles $250-$1k Reimbursement Rates 80%-100%
MONTHLY COST $18-$28

Pros and Cons

Pros Offers multiple wellness coverage options No waiting periods for wellness coverage Typically reimburses wellness claims within 24 hours Cons Takes up to two weeks to reimburse insurance claims 30-day waiting period for cancer

Why Wagmo Is a Good Option

Wagmo, which we’ve given 4.3 out of 5 stars, is a wellness-first provider. Pet owners in Missouri can opt for standalone wellness coverage or purchase an insurance policy to protect their wallets from vet bills resulting from an unexpected injury or illness.

Show-Me State pet owners can take advantage of Wagmo’s wellness plan immediately, but they must wait 15 days before accidents and illnesses are covered — and 30 days before cancer treatment is covered. Keep in mind that the company caps reimbursements at $10,000 per incident and $100,000 for the pet’s lifetime.

Wagmo Pricing and Coverage By Plan

After submitting several quotes for representative pets, we found that the average price for a Wagmo policy in Missouri is $23 per month. Compare that to expected out-of-pocket pet care costs without insurance, and Show-Me State pet owners could save $555 per year by having a Wagmo policy.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dog Insurance $28
Cat Insurance $18

Wagmo offers three levels of wellness plans, including:

  • Value plan: $25 per month for dogs and cats
  • Classic plan: $45 per month for dogs and cats
  • Deluxe plan: $65 per month for dogs and cats

Fetch Pet Insurance

Our Pick for Comprehensive Coverage
4.3
Our Rating
Annual Limits $5k-$15k Deductibles $250-$500 Reimbursement Rates 70%-90%
MONTHLY COST $42-$95

Pros and Cons

Pros Covers dental injury and disease in every adult tooth Includes coverage for breed-specific issues Offers wellness coverage options Cons Requires a six-month wait before covering certain orthopedic conditions Limits annual coverage to $15,000

Why Fetch Is a Good Option

We’ve awarded Fetch 4.3 out of 5 stars and named it our top pick for comprehensive coverage. The company offers coverage for sick visits, including exam fees, breed-specific issues and dental injury and disease in every adult tooth. However, all that comprehensive coverage comes at a price.

Fetch doesn’t have any enrollment fees, and policyholders can cancel risk-free for up to 30 days after enrollment.

Fetch Pricing and Coverage By Plan

Based on sample quotes we received, the average cost of a Fetch plan for Missouri pet parents is $69 per month. When we compared that to the out-of-pocket costs of pet ownership, we concluded that Missouri pet owners could save $6 per year with Fetch. Depending on your unique circumstances, comprehensive coverage may outweigh the cost.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dog Insurance $95
Cat Insurance $42

Fetch policyholders can add on wellness coverage for an additional $11 to $32 per month.

Trupanion

Our Pick for Unlimited Lifetime Payouts
4.2
Our Rating
Annual Limits Unlimited Deductibles $0-$1k Reimbursement Rates 90%
MONTHLY COST $33-$80

Pros and Cons

Pros Covers many conditions such as hereditary and breed-specific conditions, which aren’t covered by most providers we reviewed No extended waiting periods for orthopedic conditions Covers prescription food, supplements and herbal therapy Cons Doesn’t accept pets for coverage after their 14th birthday No wellness coverage

Why Trupanion Is a Good Option

Scoring 4.2 out of 5 stars based on our review methodology, Trupanion is our top pick for unlimited lifetime payouts. The company’s policies offer comprehensive coverage including hereditary and breed-specific conditions, advanced dentistry, diagnostic tests, allergies, medications, veterinary supplements, prescription food and herbal therapy. Trupanion also pays partnering veterinarians directly, eliminating the need to file claims after your pet receives care as with traditional insurance.

Some Missouri pet owners may not like that Trupanion doesn’t offer an option for wellness coverage, and also doesn’t cover exam fees.

Trupanion Pricing and Coverage By Plan

Based on the sample quotes we received, Missouri pet owners can expect to pay on average $56 per month for a Trupanion policy. Compared to pet health care costs, we found that a Show-Me State pet parent could save $157 per year by investing in a Trupanion policy.

Accident and Illness Coverage Monthly Cost
Dog Insurance $80
Cat Insurance $33

Trupanion doesn’t provide Missouri pet owners with the option to add on wellness coverage, but their plans can be customized by adjusting the reimbursement rate and deductible.


Compare the Top Pet Insurance Providers in Missouri

Each pet insurance provider offers different coverage options and customization capabilities, which is why it’s worth comparing offerings to determine which provider and policy best fits your needs. Our comparison tool evaluates providers side by side.

Company Monthly Cost Star Rating Accident Waiting Period BBB Rating Visit Site
$34-$75
4.5
14 days A- EXPLORE PLANS
$24-$54
4.0
15 days A+ EXPLORE PLANS
$25-$54
4.7
1 day B EXPLORE PLANS
$39-$73
4.7
48 hours A+ EXPLORE PLANS
$22-$46
4.3
15 days B- EXPLORE PLANS
$45-$90
4.3
up to 15 days A+ EXPLORE PLANS
$53-$123
4.2
48 hours A+ EXPLORE PLANS
Company BBB Rating Monthly Cost Star Rating Accident Waiting Period Visit Site
A- $34-$75
4.5
14 days EXPLORE PLANS
A+ $24-$54
4.0
15 days EXPLORE PLANS
B $25-$54
4.7
1 day EXPLORE PLANS
A+ $39-$73
4.7
48 hours EXPLORE PLANS
B- $22-$46
4.3
15 days EXPLORE PLANS
A+ $45-$90
4.3
up to 15 days EXPLORE PLANS
A+ $53-$123
4.2
48 hours EXPLORE PLANS
No results were found.

How Much Does Pet Insurance Cost in Missouri?

To determine pricing, pet insurance providers consider several factors such as your geographic location and your pet’s age and breed. Premium prices typically increase as your pet gets older, and policies for purebred pets are usually more expensive.

When determining the average prices for pet insurance in Missouri, we requested quotes from 11 popular providers for sample pets including a 5-year-old male mixed-breed dog, a 2-year-old female golden retriever, a 5-year-old male mixed breed cat and a 2-year-old female Siamese cat. Based on these results, we’ve determined that the average cost for a pet insurance policy in the Show-Me State is $57 per month for a dog and $25 for a cat.

ProviderDog InsuranceCat Insurance
Lemonade$28$13
Spot$78$29
Embrace$68$35
Healthy Paws$51$20
Fetch$95$42
Figo$42$19
Pets Best$47$22
Paw Protect$69$36
ASPCA Pet Health Insurance$37$17
ManyPets$27$14
Trupanion$80$33

What’s the Cheapest Pet Insurance in Missouri?

Based on our quote collection process, we determined that Lemonade and ManyPets are the cheapest pet insurance providers in Missouri. While these providers offer good coverage, price alone shouldn’t be the only factor you consider when choosing a pet insurance policy. Many elements should be evaluated before settling on a provider and a plan.


How To Choose the Best Pet Insurance in Missouri

Missouri pet owners should consider several factors when choosing an insurance provider and plan, such as:

  • Coverage: Most insurance providers offer accidental-only plans, which cover only accidental injuries, and accident and illness plans. These provide more comprehensive care, but at a higher cost. Many providers we reviewed sell wellness plans that you can tack on for an additional monthly fee. 
  • Fine print: Limitations, exclusions and explanations of the claims process can be found in the fine print. For this reason, it might be a good idea to read a sample policy before signing up for coverage.
  • Customization: Most providers allow you to customize your plan by adjusting your deductible, annual limit and reimbursement rate. Look for providers that offer increased flexibility to help you find a premium that fits your budget.
  • Customer satisfaction: Reading customer reviews from unbiased sites — Trustpilot, for example — can provide valuable insights into a provider’s strengths, weaknesses and customer support capabilities.

Not every pet insurance provider is available in every state. Ensure the provider you’re interested in services your area before expending time and energy researching their offerings.


Pet Laws in Missouri

Pet laws are established to protect residents, pets and wildlife, and regulate issues, including vaccinations, restraint and animal cruelty. Missouri state law mandates that all dogs and cats four months old and up must be vaccinated for rabies. Here are laws enforced in cities around the state.

Kansas City Pet Laws

  • Every dog and cat living within the city limits must have a current city license displayed on its collar at all times, according to our research
  • Kansas City doesn’t have a leash law for cats, which means animal health officers can’t impound stray cats.
  • Owning a pit bull is legal in Kansas City, but they must be spayed or neutered.

St. Louis Pet Laws

  • No more than four dogs and cats can be kept on a property within a residential-zoned district, according to our research.
  • Pets must be leashed and held by a responsible person whenever off the owner’s property, unless at a city-designated dog exercise park.
  • Pets can’t be tethered outside for more than 10 continuous hours.

Springfield Pet Laws

  • Owning a pit bull in the city is unlawful, according to our research.
  • Selling pets on a roadside, commercial parking lot or in a public area is prohibited.
  • Dogs kept within the city cannot be tethered as a means of confinement or restraint.

Understanding Pet Insurance Terminology

Knowing some key pet insurance terms will help you in your search. These are the ones you’re most likely to come across:

  • Virtually all pet insurance companies we reviewed impose waiting periods to help prevent fraud. This is the delay between buying a policy and the beginning of coverage. The provider may stipulate a relatively short period — often two days — for accidents and an extended period of six or 12 months for orthopedic conditions, according to our findings.
  • The deductible is the amount you must pay toward your pet’s veterinary bill in a given year before the insurance company will start contributing to your pet care costs. Most companies allow you to choose your deductible amount — a lower deductible correlates with a higher premium.
  • Your premium is the monthly fee you pay for your pet’s coverage. The premium is determined by several factors, including your geographic location, your pet’s age and breed, the extent of coverage and your chosen deductible and reimbursement rate.
  • The reimbursement rate is the percentage of each bill your provider will pay after you meet your deductible. 
  • The policy’s coverage limit is the maximum amount the provider will pay. Limits may apply on a per-incident, per-year or lifetime basis.

Is Pet Insurance Worth It in Missouri?

Pet insurance can save Missouri pet owners a significant amount, especially if your pet experiences a veterinary emergency. Just one emergency veterinary bill can cost more than a couple years of pet health insurance premiums. Plus, you get the peace of mind that your four-legged family members can get the care they need when sick or injured.

Based on our findings, the best pet insurance plans for Show-Me State pet owners are Spot, Healthy Paws and Figo, but we suggest you research multiple providers before deciding on a policy. Request quotes from at least three providers to help ensure you’re getting the best deal possible and the right policy for your pet’s needs.


Frequently Asked Questions About Pet Insurance in Missouri

According to data collected by Healthy Paws, common pet insurance claims in Missouri include skin conditions and ear infections, which can be exacerbated by Missouri’s long, hot and humid summers. However, a pet insurance provider won’t exclude these conditions just because you live in Missouri. These conditions may be covered unless your pet exhibited signs either before you purchased the policy or during the waiting period.

Missouri is home to numerous snake species, and if your pet is bitten, it can rack up a hefty veterinary bill including exam fees, hospital stays, intravenous fluids, medications and rechecks. Pet insurance covers snake bite treatments, which can save you a considerable amount of money if your pet encounters a venomous snake while exploring.

A waiting period is the delay between signing up for a policy and the beginning of coverage. According to our research, pet insurance waiting periods in Missouri may range from two to 14 days for accidents, 14 to 15 days for illnesses and six to 12 months for orthopedic conditions. In some cases, extended waiting periods for orthopedic conditions can be waived if your pet undergoes an exam.


How We Ranked the Best Pet Insurance Providers in Missouri

To determine Missouri pet insurance provider rankings, we considered several factors, such as policy availability in the state, pricing, customer satisfaction, customization options and provider reputation. We also looked at in-house survey results from Missouri pet owners who answered questions about how well they thought the insurance provider performed. Taking in all of this data, we gave each provider a star rating.

To obtain pricing information, we requested sample quotes from each provider for representative pets including a 5-year-old medium, mixed-breed male dog, a 2-year-old female golden retriever, a 5-year-old mixed-breed male cat and a 2-year-old female Siamese cat. If you are interested in finding out more about our quote collection process, star rating or provider rankings, you can visit our full pet insurance methodology and editorial guidelines pages.


Additional Pet Insurance Resources

Ryan Lasker Editor

Ryan Lasker is a financial writer and editor with bylines in Morning Brew, The Motley Fool, and several more. As a certified public accountant, he leverages his technical expertise in personal finance and tax to fuel his passion for teaching financial literacy. When he’s not writing, editing or working in a spreadsheet, he’s biking the D.C. trails or reading.

Angela Beal, DVM Doctor of Veterinary Medicine

Angela Beal, DVM, loves using her writing to help pet owners provide the best possible care for their furry companions. Angela has worked in private practice and taught veterinary technicians for 15 years. Since 2020, she has worked full-time with Rumpus Writing and Editing, a veterinary-specific writing and editing company. Angela lives in Columbus, Ohio with her husband, two sons, and their spoiled Chihuahua mix, Yogi.

Array
(
    [display] => Array
        (
        )

    [icon] => 
    [text] => 
    [cta] => Array
        (
            [title] => 
            [url] => 
            [target] => _blank
        )

    [toggle] => closeable
)